Gaspee Virtual Archives 
Research Notes on Robert Sutton (1741-1811)

The Gaspee Days Committee at www.gaspee.COM is a civic-minded nonprofit organization that operates many community events in and around Pawtuxet Village, including the famous Gaspee Days Parade each June. These events are all designed to commemorate the burning of the hated British revenue schooner, HMS Gaspee, by Rhode Island patriots in 1772 as 'America's First Blow for Freedom'®.  Our historical research center, the Gaspee Virtual Archives at www.gaspee.ORG , has presented these research notes as an attempt to gather further information on one who has been suspected of being associated with the the burning of the Gaspee. Please e-mail your comments or further questions to webmaster@gaspee.org.

This web page presents research notes on Robert Sutton only.  None of the information is considered authoritative at the present time.

We know little about this individual who are investigating to see if he was a true revolutionary patriot who helped burn the Gaspee in 1772.   The following snippets are all we have gathered as of July 2002:

Evidence of Robert Sutton's participation in the attack on the Gaspee
Source: http://www.rootsweb.com/~rigenweb/article31.html
From: History of Providence County, Vol I & II
Ed. by Richard M. Bayles; W.W. Preston & Co., NY.  1891
Biographical sketches, "Town of East Providence" Volume II
p. 174: Albert F. SUTTON, son of Captain William and Elizabeth (Mathews) Sutton, was born in 1839 in Seekonk, now East Providence, and was educated at Seekonk academy and Scholfield's commercial school, Providence.  He built his present house about 1873.  He has followed the gardening business, and has also turned his attention considerably to real estate.  He followed the sea about ten years.  He married first Phebe, daughter of George Rice of North Providence.  His present wife is Elizabeth, daughter of William L. Williams of Providence.  His father was a sea captain.  His grandfather, Robert Sutton, was one of the twelve men who, disguised as Indians, helped to burn the "Gaspee", as Gaspee Point.  His grandmother on his mother's side was a Lawrence, of a family of tories, located at Rehoboth, Mass.
Biographical notes:
From: Vital Records of Rehoboth by James Arnold 1897
Source: http://www.angelfire.com/ri/reaspage/revwar.html
Soldiers of The Revolution: This roll was made up Aug. 1, 1775, and paid by State and paid by United States the the last 5 months.------------
A Muster Roll of the company under command of Capt. John Perry in Col. Timothy Walker's Regimant enlisted for 8 months t the 1st of August, 1775.
Capt. John Perry, Lieut. John Paine, Ensign James Buklin, Sergeant Robert Sutton, ......
This is very likely our Robert Sutton.  He is NOT listed in the HeritageQuest Revolutionary War pension applicants, perhaps because he died in 1811 before these were set up for routine pensioners.

From fellow researcher Leonard Bucklin:

The James Bucklin, Ensign,  is a good chance of being a relative of the shooter Joseph Bucklin. Joseph's uncle, John Bucklin, was a captain of the Rehoboth Minute Company in 1774 which was incorporated into Col. Walkers regiment. We have a problem finding a James Bucklin of the right age, though.

John G. Erhardt, History of Rehoboth, Seekonk, Mass., Pawtucket & East Providence, RI, 1692-1812,  (PO Box 33, 500 Fall River Av., Seekonk, MA, 1990), p724, says there was a Joseph Bucklin who marched as a Sergeant, with the Minute Man Company of Rehoboth on the Alarm, with two Bucklins as privates, in the company of Capt. Bishop. (Query whether this was Joseph Bucklin the 4th or Joseph Bucklin the 5th, the shooter?   Erhardt's notes don't help with the identity, but it this puts Sutton in the military probably with either the Gaspee shooter or his father).

According to the early American Newspaper collection, available through NEHGS,  a Robert Sutton and others were assigned the town position as 'corders of fire-wood' in 1801 and 1804.  A curious ad in 1805 requested the sale of cider to be delivered to the houses in India Point of either Robert Sutton or James Daggett. An even more curious letter to the editor was published in 1807 from a black free man that alludes to Robert Sutton being a cruel toll collector for the Washington Bridge (that at that time was owned by the descendants of John Brown).  In 1808 Robert Sutton's name was published on a list of persons who were delinquent in their property tax. Finally, in 1812 an executor notice was published for his estate by a Samuel Mason.
Genealogical Notes:
http://www.sutton.org/issue16.htm and http://www.max-muller.com/m-muller/aqwg12.htm (Stale link 2006)
412. Robert SUTTON 1 died 28 Apr 1753 in Rehoboth, MA. He married Jerusha ALLEN on 13 Sep 1737 in Rehoboth, MA.
These would likely be our Robert Sutton's parents.

Source: http://www.max-muller.com/at01/at01_008.htm (Stale link 2006) Ahnentafel Report

206 Robert SUTTON.  Born on 19 July 1741 in Rehoboth, MA. Robert died in Providence, Rhode Island, U.S.A. on 15 November 1811, he was 70.
This is likely the Robert Sutton of our concern.  He's not recorded a being buried in Rhode Island, and is probably in a family plot in the Eastern suburb of Rehoboth, MA. 

Rhode Island Historical Cemetery Database comes up negative on a Robert Sutton.  He also doesn't show up on the 1790 Federal census. In pinging GENDEX, there are too many Robert Suttons dating back to the 10th Century for me to pick one suspect out.  None pique our interest with visible ties to Rhode Island or Rehoboth, however.

By backwards searches of relatives in Gendex however, we do get that our Robert Sutton was married in 1761 to a Rhoda Lloyd (1740-1827) who died in Providence.  They had at least one other child besides Captain William Sutton, a Rhoda Sutton, born in 1766.  There's no Rhoda Sutton buried in RI either, even though we know she died in Providence, so Robert's wife was probably buried with him in Rehoboth or somewhere.

There is one Jerusha Allen born in Manchester, MA in 1712 at the right time to be our Robert Sutton's mother, but this is North of Boston, a considerable distance in those days from Rehoboth.  I've been unable to closely relate Jerusha with Gaspee raider Paul Allen.

According to Ancestry.com searches, supplemented by B. Charles Sutton and by Bob Sutton: and by Nancy Carney

Children of Robert Sutton and Jerusha Allen were:
  1.  Rebecca SUTTON b: 18 MAR 1737/38 in Rehoboth, Bristol, MA m Jeremiah BLY
  2.  Robert SUTTON b: 19 JUL 1741 in Rehoboth, Bristol, MA
  3.  Sarah SUTTON b: 11 JUL 1744 in Rehoboth, Bristol, MA m Miles SHOREY
  4.  Benjamin SUTTON b: 29 JAN 1746/47 in Rehoboth, Bristol, MA
  5.  Jerusha SUTTON b: 16 JAN 1749/50 in Rehoboth, Bristol, MA m Charles GOFF
  6.  Hannah SUTTON b: 3 JUL 1751 in Rehoboth, Bristol, MA m Anthony JENCKES
Note that these children's father Robert Sutton, Sr died in 1753, probably leaving them all destitute.  Their mother Jerusha died c1768
Robert SUTTON
Birth: 19 Jul 1741 in Rehoboth, MA Death: 15 Nov 1811 in Providence, RI
Father: Robert SUTTON    Mother: Jerusha ALLEN
Marriage 1 Rhoda LLOYD b: 1740  d: 31 Aug 1827 in Providence  M: 10 Sep 1761 in Rehoboth,MA
Children:
  1. Diadama  SUTTON b 16Sep1762, married Robert Crocker
  2. John SUTTON b. 15Feb1764 in Rehoboth, MA
  3. Rhoda SUTTON b: 14 Feb 1766 in Rehoboth, MA married Charles Freeman
  4. Polly SUTTON b 6Feb1768 in Rehoboth, MA
  5. Robert b 25Jan1770 later moved c1807 to PA then to the Upstate area of  NY
  6. ? Charles SUTTON (b after 1774) m Elizabeth, also moved c1807 to PA then to the Upstate area of  NY, and died there after 1840.
  7. Oliver SUTTON b 31Mar1777 in Providence, RI, d19Oct1828 buried in Rumford, RI-a musician
  8. Captain William SUTTON b 8January1781 in Seekonk, MA d. Dec 13, 1853 buried in Rumford, RI. married1: Rachel MATHEWS, married2 Elizabeth MATHEWS
  9. Russell Sutton b 14 Dec1782 in Rehoboth, MA
  10. Polly Sutton b 15 Mar1784.  By convention, this second Polly probably means that the Polly of 1768 died as a child.

Robert Sutton was probably descended from the Mayflower line. I've also come to the conclusion that there was a big connection between the sleepy farm town of Rehoboth, Massachusetts and the many family ties of the people from Providence who burnt the Gaspee.

In October, 2003, we received the following e-mail excerpt from B. Charles Sutton, a descendant:

Some of my information is simply family stories passed through the generations, BUT, there is sufficient evidence, in my opinion, that substantiate the "stories".   The story, as you have it, that Robert was one of the 12 dressed as Indians is as it has been told in the family.  Robert was a sea captain, as many, many of my ancestors were and he kept boats in Bristol.   Several naming conventions in my family have been used to "memorialize" the acts of Robert and his raider friends.  Note that Ephraim Bowen was one of the raiders; he was a personal friend of Robert, and one of my ancestors was named in his honor (Bowen Sutton).  My great-great Grandfather Nathaniel, also a sea captain, started the Providence Steamboat company (still in operation at India Point in Providence today).  One of his earlier tugs was named after the Gaspee, this was intentionally named in Robert's honor, although it was retired and is currently in dry dock.  Another tells that Robert participated due to that fact that our family was very close to the Williams' (yes, as in Roger Williams), and the British brutality was seen as a slap in the face to the "people" of family friends.  Robert's patriotic nature and devotion to the honor of family friends made it an easy decision for him.  Not to mention that family members, including Robert, were of those harassed by the Gaspee and her crew.
In January 2003, we received an e-mail from a WJH, claiming descendancy from Robert Sutton, and who claims Robert Sutton operated a ferry-boat service. From LDS files we have his granddaughter, Rhoda Lloyd Sutton born 1794 in Thompson, CT.  WJH feels that her family moved eventually to the Pennsylvania area.

In July 2003, we received an e-mail from ASR:

Robert and Rhoda had a first child Diadamia from whom I am descended. Also you say that there was a  Jerusha Allen born in MA at the time she would have been born. That Allen family had a son who went to Rehoboth after his first wife died and remarried again there. Quite a few Jerushas have shown up in this family.
In July 2006 we received a volumnous e-mail from Bob Sutton of Southern California, who did extensive, detailed research on his ancestors leading back to, and beyond, our Gaspee raider Robert Sutton.  He relates a long known family story of their great5grandfather having been involved with the Revolution in Rhode Island, and states that the Sutton families all have a long history of naming their first born sons Robert in honor of the Robert Sutton that helped burn the Gaspee in 1772. He confims and supplements the genealogy files noted above.  He also adds:
I found that [local map-maker] Mr. Chace did another study from 1798 at the LDS library, and low, and behold, there are two Sutton’s indicated: Robert and Charles C.  The study included a nice little map that shows Robert’s property right at India Point, where the park is now, and just short of the bridge. James Daggett has the property next door.  In 1992 I spent three or four days there at the time the Brown University boathouse was right about where I think Robert Sutton’s place was. Looking at Microsofts new www.local.live.com with aerial and bird's eye photos they must have redone the park with a new, much bigger boathouse.
 
Property records are available and I copied the record of the sale of this property, and it turns out that Robert bought this place from …. John Brown… I have at some point learned that the bridge was built in 1793, and was owned by John Brown and maybe his brother Moses. In any case, it indicates to me that John Brown and Robert Sutton had some relationship.  I don’t think that John Brown needed to sell that little parcel or place, but did Robert Sutton need to or just want to buy it?
 
Chace 1798Son Charles owned, or co-owned a place with R. Hudson, just around the corner, up the street, right about where the Days Inn, or Radisson nowadays, is now.  Or possibly under I-195.  I don’t think that I ever was able to decipher who the seller was for this property.
 
Whether Robert Sutton was a sea captain or owned ships, as B.Charles has heard, is uncertain to to me.  I’ve not found any evidence.  My guess, my hunch is that he probably spent most of his adult and working life associated with the Brown family, and living nearby at least.  John Brown was, as we all know, quite a mover and shaker, and had a lot of stuff going on, all that needed help in the form of employees and contractors. I would bet that Robert Sutton was part of the Brown, Inc. organization for most of his life and livelihood.  Again, I don’t have much evidence, but I can say I’ve looked in a lot of places for information as to Robert's livelihood.

Right:  Inset of 1798 Map of Providence as presented in Chace, Henry R. Owners and Occupants of the Lots, Houses, and Shops in the Town of Providence, Rhode Island in 1798, published 1914. Notice R. Sutton's house located just west of the India Bridge, which was actually named by owner John Brown as the George Washington Bridge.

The only Sutton we find on the 1770 List of Providence Taxpayers is a Bartholemew Sutton, whose home was located at the intersection of North Main Street and Town Street, between the Smith Distillery and the Antram Distillery. Perhaps then, he may have been involved with the Triangular trade like many Gaspee raiders. Search on all other genealogical databases is negative for a Bart Sutton from Rhode Island, the only one found being buried in Pennsylvania. The RI Historical Cemeteries Database does however give us a Bart Sutton, and presumably his toddler son (could be grandson) buried in the Old North Burial Grounds, next door to their homestead.
SUTTON         BARTHOLOMEW                       1699c -  8 SEP 1775    PV001
SUTTON         BARTHOLOMEW                       1752c - 17 NOV 1754    PV001
This Bart Sutton would've been the right age and location to have been an uncle of grandfather of Robert Sutton, but this is all highly speculative. Of the remaining Suttons listed, only the following have 18th century birth dates.  Those with EP003 burial sites are in the Newman Cemetery in East Providence, RI, earlier part of Rehoboth, MA. And since they were born after Bart's death in 1775, they can't be his kids, so they must be someone else's, perhaps Robert's.
SUTTON         OLIVER                            1777c - 19 OCT 1828    EP003
SUTTON         SARAH                             1779c - 16 DEC 1831    EP003
Sharon McElroy, a descendant, indicates that the Oliver Sutton above married a Sarah Bucklin on 17 Feb 1799 in Rehoboth, MA, and this has been confirmed by B. Charles Sutton with gravesite research.

The Gaspee Days Committee recognizes Robert Sutton as a true American patriot for his role in attacking the HMS Gaspee in 1772.

That's all the evidence we have for now folks. If you know more, please e-mail us at webmaster@gaspee.org.  Thanks!
Back to Top    |    Back to Gaspee Virtual Archives
Originally Posted to Gaspee Virtual Archives 7/2002    Last Revised 6/2007    RobertSutton.html